While East Devon looks set to spend even more fighting Unitary Devon, local government still needs a shake up

Sarah Randall-Johnson, the parliamentary seat-chasing Tory leader of East Devon District Council who spent loadsa money fighting the seemingly inevitable progression of a Devon Unitary Council, has said of the latest unitary edict: “The only thing more surprising than the ridiculous single Devon unitary proposal is the period of time allowed for the public to comment – six weeks, to include the distraction of the Christmas and New Year holidays.”

The festive season notwithstanding, do people care whether they have a unitary council, a district council, or a metropolitan council? We think not. As long as the bins are collected, services are delivered and the council tax is kept low, most people, we reckon, would have no thought about the structure their council.

In terms of local democracy, let’s not forget that East Devon ignored public opinion as it made the decision to allow Tesco to be build in Seaton, and that sitting in on the welcoming committee was a councillor who hadn’t even been elected.

The current make up of councillors taking seats at both district and county level means the community is short-changed. The proposed siting of the Ivybridge Incinerator, is an example: “Ivybridge’s local councillor on Devon County Council, Cllr Roger Croad, being at the same time the Executive member responsible for waste, the chair of the South West Waste Partnership that is looking for a new location for an incinerator and Ivybridge’s Town Councillor who should be opposing the plans”.

The leader of Torridge Council, James Morrish, told the North Devon Gazette: “The only good thing to come out of the whole argument for a unitary authority is that we as a council have found more cost-effective ways of running a local authority, such as appointing a joint chief executive and sharing the skills pool with Teignbridge District Council.”

Which kinda supports the whole notion of a unitary council in the first place.

He also said: “Although the fate of local government is uncertain, while we are still here – and we could well be for a number of years – we need to keep our eye on the ball and continue to do all we can to provide the best possible services at the lowest possible cost.”

It will be interesting to see how the Tory-led County Council faces up to the unitary issue with the Tory-led East Devon Council, especially if we get a Tory-led Government, who will be looking to make savings on services and pension payments. And it will also be interesting to see if the people of East Devon appreciate the money and energy being spent by their district council on fighting the boundary commission, come the next district council elections.

Sarah finishes her press release by saying: “We will be taking legal advice and consulting with our partner authorities on what steps we may be able to take in opposing this absurd idea.”

And we all know how inexpensive legal advice is…

• We’ve had just two examples of local democracy not working – got anymore? Comments below, please!



book a hotel in Devon Come and enjoy Devon – book a hotel and get away!




Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Related posts:

  1. Democracy postponed! Exeter local elections cancelled because of unitary plans! Exeter City Council has cancelled the elections that were due...
  2. Council boundary bugbears posted by Cptn Devon County Council has welcomed the decision...
  3. The Plymouth Citybus sale shows there’s no democracy in local politics. Lib Dem Stuart Bonar has the answer Plymouth City Council Conservatives managed to sell off the council's...
Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Press release from Mid Devon District Council
Last chance to have your say on proposed new super-council for Devon

Comments to Secretary of State by Tuesday 19 January 2010

The Boundary Committee, which was asked by the Government to look into possible alternative ways of structuring councils in Devon, has now made its recommendation for a single unitary council covering the whole of Devon (apart from Plymouth and Torbay).

The creation of a single unitary council would replace the existing county council and district councils. The Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government will make the final decision about whether or not to follow the advice of the Boundary Committee and has set a deadline of Tuesday 19 January 2010 for the public to comment.

Council Leader Peter Hare-Scott says said "While the Boundary Committee and the Government have been dragging out this process for years, we have been quietly getting on with the real issues that matter – helping our residents and businesses get through the recession, providing good services to local people and, increasingly, working with other councils to find more efficient ways of doing things.

“The prospect of a major upheaval in Devon is the last thing anyone needs – and, in any case, we know that two thirds of people in Mid Devon are against the idea of a super-council covering the whole county. A new super-council for Devon would have the worst level of democratic representation in the country, with a proposed 100 elected councillors representing 740,000 people – that’s one councillor working for 7,400 people!

“And you only have to look across the border to Cornwall to see the folly of this proposal. The cost of scrapping the county and district councils and creating a new unitary Cornwall Council was supposed to be about £20million but the actual costs tripled to nearly £60 million. If this were repeated in Devon, it would be at least 10 years before any benefits were shown.

“Along with all the other district councils, we will be lobbying hard during the six-week consultation period to get Ministers to drop the idea of imposing unwanted change from on high and instead let us get on with the process of closer collaboration with other councils that we’ve already started. If you feel strongly about this too, then make sure your tell the Secretary of State”.

How to make your views known

From 8 December 2009 to 19 January 2010 you can submit your views about the Boundary Committee’s proposal or about retaining the existing two-tier structure of county and district councils by emailing devonstructures@communities.gsi.gov.uk or by writing to:

Unitary Structures Team
Department for Communities and Local Government
Zone 3/J1
Eland House
Bressenden Place
London SW1E 5DU

Devon Structural Review

See http://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/boundary-rev...

We picked this up and thought it was pertinant:
"Luke Pollard, Labour’s Prospective Parliamentary Candidate in South West Devon, has written to Cllr Roger Croad asking him to resign from his waste portfolio on Devon County Council over a conflict of interest over Ivybridge residents’ campaign against Viridor’s incinerator proposals."

http://www.labourmatters.com/devon-labour/ivybridg...

Following the Boundary Committee's announcement yesterday (7 December 2009), Councillor Peter Hare-Scott, Leader of Mid Devon District Council, said "While the Boundary Committee and the Government have been dragging out this process for years, we have been quietly getting on with the real issues that matter – helping our residents and businesses get through the recession, providing good services to local people and, increasingly, working with other councils to find more efficient ways of doing things.

“The prospect of a major upheaval in Devon is the last thing anyone needs – and, in any case, we know that two thirds of people in Mid Devon are against the idea of a super-council covering the whole county.

“Along with all the other district councils, we will be lobbying hard during the six-week consultation period to get Ministers to drop the idea of imposing unwanted change from on high and instead let us get on with the process of closer collaboration with other councils that we’ve already started.”